The Movie Insider

New Movie Updates and The Insider Feed

2009 MOVIES COMING SOON

news headlines

Friday, May 16, 2008 12:39 AM EDT

The Choice to Make a 'Bioshock' Movie



Comments  

Written by Philip Friedman, Lee's Movie Info

A godsend for Bioshock fans: Uwe Boll will not direct the movie version. Granted, that was an extremely unlikely possibility, but there are plenty of directors that would have been almost as bad. Video games to movies have been nowhere close to as successful as comic books, commercially or critically. In fact, they've mostly been costly embarrassments regardless of the director. I thought the under-appreciated "Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within" was a technical masterpiece that had an interesting although convoluted story. Yet, despite Sony's efforts, critics disparaged it (44% on RottenTomatoes) and box office results created a financial disaster ($140 million production budget, $32.1 million domestic box office). Although there have been box office successes like Lara Croft: Tomb Raider ($80 million budget, $131.1 million domestic), they're usually critically trashed (Lara managed just 19% on RottenTomatoes) and haven't come close to matching the amazing box office and critical results of comic movies like X-Men, Spider-Man and this month's Iron Man. Why get stuck doing video game remakes, with a best-case scenario of a Resident Evil type franchise, when there is plenty of untapped comic book material out there?

If anyone could turn around the video game spin-off genre, it is Gore Verbinski (Pirates of the Caribbean movies) and that's likely why Universal and Take-Two decided to bring him aboard for Bioshock. He managed the miraculous theme park ride to movie translation that grossed Disney over a billion in domestic box office ($305.4M + $423.0M + $309.4M = $1,037.8M) and won critics over (at least the first one did). As a fan of Bioshock, would he be my top choice? No, I'd probably go with Darren Aronofsky, but that would likely come at the cost of funding issues, delays and a much lower box office—it would be nice to see a sequel or two. If one were to graph directors using the variables of commercial success and artistic integrity, Verbinski would represent one of the best trade-offs, although I'll have to go back and watch "The Mexican" and "Mousehunt".

For those who haven't played Bioshock, or did but didn't enjoy it, a movie version could seem like yet another zombies-run-amok movie simply set underwater. It could easily turn into that type of movie and that would be a sad waste of the franchise. I borrowed Bioshock after hearing an onslaught of amazing reviews. I didn't see how a seemingly standard first person shooter could be that amazing. Despite an apparently open-ended beginning, it began to look a lot like the linear, run-around-in-corridors-and-beat-zombies-with-a-blunt-object-type game, but there was a lingering mystery that kept me playing. In fact, the game play was almost a distraction; I played only to learn more about the world of Rapture. About 10 to 12 hours later, I had answers and I badly wanted to see a movie version. Unlike the Xbox signature title, Halo (which currently sits in development hell), Bioshock offered an intricate character-driven story that wouldn't break the bank with effects.

Yet, there are seemingly insurmountable hurdles for the movie to clear. The game reveals critical spoilers that are fundamental to the story, but also diminish the value of a second viewing. Once one knows those secrets, it's not going to be as exciting, but if they decide to change those secrets, how can the movie be faithful to the original story? Yes, the atmosphere and set design could be awe-inspiring. Seeing a Big Daddy on the big screen will be exciting, but that merely sets the mood. For the movie to be complete, we will have to care about the characters. For those of us that liked the game, we did that, but we know how it ends. Can Verbinski breath a new life (or inject some Adam) into Jack? I don't know, but at least there's hope now. I'll be in line for the Bioshock movie on some Friday in 2010 (as of writing this, there is no official release date).

RECENT NEWS HEADLINES

IMAX Experience Now at Two AMC Theatres in Metro Detroit

AMC Entertainment Inc., a leading theatrical exhibition and entertainment company, announces today that guests visiting AMC Livonia 20 and AMC Star Great Lakes 25 can now enjoy The IMAX Experience from IMAX Corporation. .

Barrymore and Long are 'Going the Distance'

In a odd twist of events, Drew Barrymore has signed on to star opposite her former boyfriend Justin Long in Going the Distance, a romantic comedy for New Line Cinema, according to The Hollywood Reporter. Adam Shankman (Bedtime Stories) and Jennifer Gibgot are producing via their Offspring Entertainment banner, and Nanette Burstein is directing. The story by first-time scribe Geoff LaTulippe follows a couple trying to maintain a long-distance relationship..

Winners Announced for 'DVD Contest'

To celebrate the launch of PowerPlay, The Movie Insider has announced the winners of The Ultimate DVD Contest!.

Reeves to Lead Actioner 'Bebop'

Keanu Reeves, who most recently starred in The Day the Earth Stood Still, has signed to lead the cast of actioner Cowboy Bebop, according to Daily Variety. Reeves will take on the role of lead bounty hunter Spike Spiegel. Cowboy Bebop, a Japanese animated series, tells the story of a group of interstellar bounty hunters and their adventures aboard the starship Bebop..

Whitaker Confirmed in Talks for 'Expendables'

Forest Whitaker, who was recently seen in Vantage Point and Street Kings, has been confirmed to be in negotiating to join the cast of the action film The Expendables, Stallone's latest writing and directing effort, according to The Hollywood Reporter. Whitaker would play the CIA liaison for a group of mercenaries (played by Stallone, Jet Li, Randy Couture and Jason Statham) who are clandestinely sent to South America to overthrow a dictator..

Shankman to Helm 'Bob', 'Sinbad'

Director Adam Shankman, who helmed the upcoming Disney family adventure pic Bedtime Stories, will next tackle Disney's Bob the Musical and likely Sony's Sinbad, Daily Variety reported. Bob the Musical centers on a mild-mannered man who suddenly hears the "inner song" of people's hearts after being struck on the head..

Sonnenfeld to Save MGM's 'World'

Barry Sonnenfeld, who is an exec producer and director on "Pushing Daisies", will direct and produce the action comedy The How-To Guide for Saving the World for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Daily Variety reported. The project, penned by BenDavid Grabinski, refers to an instruction manual for saving the world, which is left behind by a secret group that protects the Earth from alien invaders after the group is wiped out. .

Morgan and Miller Find 'Roommates' Together

Tracy Morgan, who most recently appeared in First Sunday, will star in and produce the comedy Freshman Roommates for The Montecito Picture Company and Paramount Pictures, according to Daily Variety. TJ Miller (Cloverfield) will also star in the film. Freshman Roommates asks the question what if those spam emails aren't scams. .

Ford Teams McAdams for News Comedy

Harrison Ford, last seen in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal, will star in Morning Glory, which is a comedy that J.J. Abrams is producing for Paramount Pictures. Rachel McAdams (Wedding Crashers) is in negotiations to join the cast too. Aline Brosh McKenna (The Devil Wears Prada) wrote the script. Roger Michell (Enduring Love) is set to direct. .

F/X Wizard Stewart to Helm Horror Western

Visual effects wizard Scott Charles Stewart, who co-founded the effects house The Orphanage, has signed to direct Priest, a horror Western adapted from a TokyoPop comic book, according to The Hollywood Reporter. The story is set in a world ravaged by centuries of war between man and vampire and follows a warrior priest who turns against the church to track down a murderous band of vampires who have kidnapped his niece. .

Wilde Enters Disney's 'Tron' Sequel

Olivia Wilde, who starred in Turistas and is a series regular on Fox's medical drama "House", has signed on to star in Tron 2.0, the sequel to the 1982 Disney cult classic being directed by Joseph Kosinski, according to Daily Variety and The Hollywood Reporter. The original, about a programmer thrust into a computer and forced to fight in games he helped create, is remembered for its sci-fi gladiator-style battles and groundbreaking special effects..

Kunis Opens Warner's 'Book of Eli'

Max Payne star Mila Kunis, who is probably best known for her role in "That 70s' Show" has joined the cast of The Book of Eli, the Denzel Washington sci-fi action thriller from Warner Bros. Pictures and Alcon Entertainment, according to The Hollywood Reporter. Albert and Allen Hughes are directing the pic..

Zombie Prepping 'Halloween' Sequel

Dimension Films and writer-director Rob Zombie are teaming for a second helping of Halloween madness this October, according to Daily Variety. Zombie will write and direct H2, the sequel to his 2007 reinvention of the John Carpenter horror classic. The new film picks up right as the first remake ended, following the aftermath of Michael Myers' murderous rampage through the eyes of the sister he hunted..

Witherspoon in Brooks' Comedy Project

Helmer James L. Brooks, who has directed only five films during his career and hasn't helmed one since 2004's Spanglish, will next team up with Reese Witherspoon on How Do You Know for Sony Pictures, according to Daily Variety. Witherspoon was set to start lensing an Untitled Cameron Crowe Project for Sony in February, but that film has been pushed to July, leaving an opening in the actress' schedule..

Baruchel Fills Disney's 'Apprentice' Shoes

Jay Baruchel, who was last seen in Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist and Tropic Thunder, is negotiating to play the title role in a live-action The Sorcerer's Apprentice for Walt Disney Pictures, Daily Variety reported. Baruchel would join Nicolas Cage, who plays the sorcerer in the Jon Turteltaub-directed film..


2012 poster
1

2012 (PG-13)

$65,000,000

Avg. Gross: $19,095 in 3,404 Theaters

Cumulative Total: $65,000,000

A Christmas Carol poster
2

A Christmas Carol ()

$22,325,000

Avg. Gross: $17,184 in 3,683 Theaters

Cumulative Total: $63,289,000

The Men Who Stare at Goats poster
3

The Men Who Stare at Goats (R)

$6,200,000

Avg. Gross: $9,530 in 2,453 Theaters

Cumulative Total: $23,376,000

Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire poster
4

Precious: Based on the No... ()

$6,090,000

Avg. Gross: $51,230 in 174 Theaters

Cumulative Total: $8,914,000

This Is It poster
5

This Is It ()

$5,100,000

Avg. Gross: $22,131 in 3,037 Theaters

Cumulative Total: $67,211,000